Two boyfriends=/ Im confused on what to do?

I am currently involved with two guys. One i have been with for about 5 months and the other one for about a month. they both know about each other. They have gotten into a physical fight. One is willing to wait for me until i make up my mind. the other one would be extremely upset and probably would leave me if he knew i was still talking to guy #2. Thing is i love guy #1 we get along so perfectly. our personality's match. every girl tells me how jealous she is of how good he treats me. Guy #2 i like because he is Christian that is very important to me and my family. its what brings me to him. but idk what to do. i know i need to be with a Christan guy or ill be suffering later on.